User blog comment:CaptainMacMillan/2011 Awards/@comment-1045586-20120102131655/@comment-1045586-20120102165511

I don't care how replayable a game is. Skyrim isn't essentially replayable. You will still be doing the same thing as you would before. Riddler challenges will take you a long time, and all of the challenges are different. Also, Batman is extremely expandable. There are a multitude of Batman villains and heroes that aren't in the game yet (Clayface, Anarky, Firefly) and it's always possible to bring in more of the Justice League and their enemies. Skyrim expanspansion is basically limited to the same stuff in a new area.

Honestly, to me, Skyrim is very low on my Games of the Year.